Skip to Content

Tips to Find Great Tenants for Your Rental Property

Key Takeaways

  • Craft Compelling Listings: Utilize popular real estate platforms to post detailed descriptions and high-quality photos, attracting tenants who value well-maintained properties.​

  • Leverage Personal Networks: Tap into your personal connections by seeking referrals from friends, family, and past tenants to find trustworthy renters.​

  • Advertise Locally: Distribute flyers in neighborhood hotspots like cafes, grocery stores, and community centers to reach potential tenants seeking local accommodations.

  • Host Open Houses: Organize open house events to allow prospective tenants to view the property firsthand and engage in direct conversations, facilitating better tenant selection.

 

As a rental property owner, your primary goal is to secure great tenants who will not only pay rent on time but also treat your property with respect, ensuring long-term stability for both you and your investment.

Finding such tenants is critical to maximizing your rental income and minimizing future headaches. Great tenants not only make timely rent payments but also take care of your rental home, report maintenance issues promptly, and maintain peaceful relations with neighbors.

If you allow tenants with pets, you expand your pool of potential high-quality renters while protecting your property with clear pet policies and pet deposits.

At Real PM Services, we specialize in tenant screening and placement to ensure you get reliable, long-term renters who protect your investment. Keep reading to learn more!

 

What Sets Great Tenants Apart from the Rest?

Here are the key characteristics of ideal tenants:

  • Timely rent payments: They consistently pay rent on time without delays.
  • Property care: They treat your property with care, reducing wear and tear.
  • Maintenance awareness: They report maintenance issues quickly to prevent bigger problems.
  • Respectful living: They live harmoniously with neighbors and respect community rules.

So, how do you go about finding these great tenants? The process hinges on two critical steps: effective marketing to attract long-term tenants and thorough screening to select the right ones.

Strong marketing expands your pool of qualified applicants, including responsible renters seeking stable housing, while meticulous screening ensures you choose candidates who will pay reliably, maintain your property, and commit for years. Together, these strategies reduce turnover and protect your investment’s long-term profitability.

 

six people discussing with each other

Here’s how to succeed in both areas:

 

Marketing Tips for Attracting Quality Tenants

Display Yard Signs

Placing a simple “For Rent” sign in front of your rental property remains one of the most effective ways to generate local interest. To maximize results, ensure your sign is clean, professional-looking, and visible from the street. 

Pair this with strong curb appeal like a well-maintained lawn, fresh paint, and tidy entryway, to create instant positive first impressions. Include clear contact information so interested renters can easily reach you for details. For an even better response, consider adding a QR code that links directly to your online listing with photos and full details.

 

Post on Popular Listing Sites

Online marketing is one of the most cost-effective ways to advertise your property and reach a wide audience of potential tenants. To maximize results, post on popular real estate sites with clear, detailed descriptions, high-quality photos, and virtual tours.

This professional presentation not only attracts more applicants but also helps you secure quality tenants who appreciate well-maintained rentals.

 

Leverage Your Personal Network

Tap into your existing network to find great tenants. Talk to friends, family, colleagues, and acquaintances who might know someone looking for a rental. You can even ask for referrals from past tenants. The advantage of using personal connections is that they can vouch for potential renters’ reliability, giving you added peace of mind.

 

Advertise in Local Neighborhoods

Marketing in your local community is a great way to attract potential tenants who want to live close to their workplace, school, or family. Distribute flyers in popular local spots like cafes, grocery stores, schools, and libraries. You can also post flyers on bulletin boards at places of worship, community centers, or local events. 

 

Host an Open House

Hosting an open house gives interested applicants a chance to see the property in person, allowing them to ask questions and get a better feel for the space. It also gives you the opportunity to gauge whether they would be a good fit for your rental.

Be mindful of scheduling the open house when your current tenants are preparing to move out. Ensure the home is clean and well-presented for showings. If your tenants are still living in the unit, coordinate with them to schedule viewings at convenient times for all parties involved.

 

Ask Current Tenants for Referrals

Your current tenants can be a valuable resource when you have a vacancy. If they’re moving out, ask if they know anyone looking for a place. Offering a referral incentive can motivate them to help you find a reliable replacement, saving you time and money on marketing.

 

Tenant Screening Tips for Protecting Your Investment

Once you’ve attracted interest in your property, it’s time to screen your potential tenants thoroughly. Tenant screening helps you identify red flags and avoid the risks associated with bad tenants. These could include late payments, property damage, or legal problems. 

By following a rigorous screening process, you increase your chances of finding tenants who will be responsible, reliable, and respectful of your property.

 

person sitting on a white couch reviewing a lease agreement

Review the Application Form

Start by requiring all potential tenants to fill out an application form that collects essential information, including income, employment history, rental history, and references. 

Once they’ve completed the form, take the time to conduct an interview to verify the details they’ve provided and get a better sense of their character.

 

Run a Credit Check

A credit check is crucial in tenant screening. With the applicant’s permission, review their credit report for signs of financial instability, such as debts, bankruptcies, or evictions. While a low credit score isn’t a dealbreaker, assess whether their finances suggest they can pay rent on time.

 

Verify Income

Verify that the tenant’s income is enough to cover rent and living expenses. Request recent pay stubs or bank statements to confirm their income and check for any signs of financial instability. 

Even with a high income, it’s important to ensure they don’t have significant debts or obligations that could impact their ability to pay rent on time.

 

Check Rental History

A good rental history is one of the best indicators of a reliable tenant. Contact previous landlords to inquire about the tenant’s behavior, payment history, and how well they took care of the property. 

Look for signs of trouble such as evictions or complaints from neighbors. This information is invaluable in determining whether the tenant will be a good fit for your property.

 

Conduct a Criminal Background Check

While it’s essential to comply with fair housing laws, performing a criminal background check is still an important part of the screening process. 

Depending on the laws in your area, you may want to screen for violent crimes or other serious offenses that could affect the safety and security of your property and its residents.

 

Bottom Line

Finding great tenants takes time, but it’s worth the effort. Effective marketing and thorough screening help you attract reliable tenants who will care for your property and pay rent on time. Patience and diligence are key, whether you handle the process yourself or hire a property management company.

At Real PM Services, we turn the challenge of tenant placement into a seamless process. Our expertise in marketing, screening, and lease management ensures your property stays occupied with qualified tenants, so you can enjoy passive income without the stress. Ready to find great tenants for your rental property? Contact us today!

We are pledged to the letter and spirit of U.S. policy for the achievement of equal housing opportunity throughout the Nation. See Equal Housing Opportunity Statement for more information.

The Neighborly Done Right Promise

The Neighborly Done Right Promise ® delivered by Real Property Management, a proud Neighborly company

When it comes to finding the right property manager for your investment property, you want to know that they stand behind their work and get the job done right – the first time. At Real Property Management we have the expertise, technology, and systems to manage your property the right way. We work hard to optimize your return on investment while preserving your asset and giving you peace of mind. Our highly trained and skilled team works hard so you can be sure your property's management will be Done Right.

Canada excluded. Services performed by independently owned and operated franchises.

See Full Details